[streaming] miniSAP
Marshall Eubanks
tme at multicasttech.com
Sun Jun 29 18:15:09 CEST 2008
Dear Remi;
On Jun 29, 2008, at 5:02 AM, Rémi Denis-Courmont wrote:
> Le samedi 28 juin 2008 20:34:33 Marshall Eubanks, vous avez écrit :
>> We have been having a lot of problems recently with this program
>> blasting out SAP messages (up to 300 Mbps !), which cause multicast
>> problems.
>
> Yeah, so basically... minisap does not implement any bandiwdth
> measurement at
> the moment. Congestion control is as brain-dead as sending a packet
> every
> total delay divided by total number of _local_ announces.
>
>> Is there any possibility that this program could be changed to rate
>> limit it to < 1 Mbps or some other reasonable level ?
>
> minisap should measure the incoming SAP traffic, much like the VLC
> built-in
> SAP sender does. However the official SAP RFC limit (4kbps) sounds
> very low.
>
> That being noted, the default delay is 5 seconds, so that users wait
> no more
> than 5 seconds to get the full channels lists. If there are so many
> announces
> that you currently receive 300 Mbps of them on a single multicast
> group, it
> would mean there are the order of a million different announces.
> This seems
> unlikely high. I would suppose there is some buggy sender somewhere
> that
> sends way too fast, such as an out-of-date version (< 0.3.4) of
> miniSAP.
I will gather information about this and report back.
Regards
Marshall
>
>
> --
> Rémi Denis-Courmont
> http://www.remlab.net/
More information about the streaming
mailing list