[vlc-devel] Formal complaint - censorship
remi at remlab.net
Tue Oct 26 12:38:51 CEST 2010
----- Message d'origine -----
> - First, everyone know what you did. Including yourself, obviously.
> Your post on planet.videolan.org was meant to be understood as a PR
> from VideoLAN. While clearly it is not. It's your only your own
> personnal feeling. So go post that on your own personal blog.
This is preposterous. I have done numerous PR on behalf of the project. When I do that, I always mention it and use official means: the official website and/or the announcements mailing list. Thdi time I used my personal feed and signed with my lone name.
I find it disturbing that I am wrongly accused of impersonating the project, while you obviously benefited from advertisment by said project, and I did not. But that is to be expected when the website admins have made themselves party to the argument.
> - Now I really don't get all the hatred. MobileVLC is licensed under
> GPLv2. All the sourcecode is open, and _anyone_ can download the
> source and tinker with it. Now _some people_ assert that Apple
> distributing an app is a violation of the GPL. This remains to be
This is a matter of principles - enforcing my IPR. Besides, Apple is benefiting from indirect promotion in distributing VLC on their platform, so it is only fair that I (and others) require them to play by the rules.
> - Last, but not least : in the "spirit" of the GPL, I really can't
> see where things don't work. Sources are open, anyone can modify,
> rebuild, and run. For instance, if the app was submitted on a
> "jailbroken appstore" like Cydia, the deal wouldn't be any
It would be much different. Otherwise, you wouod not have bothered with AppStore submission to begin with.
More information about the vlc-devel