[vlc-devel] DASH access plugin

Christopher Müller christopher.mueller at itec.uni-klu.ac.at
Mon Feb 21 09:16:55 CET 2011

> 	Hello,
> Le dimanche 20 février 2011 15:46:36 Christopher Müller, vous avez écrit :
> > > Are you too shy to ask for a proper code review and submit the code?
> > > Or should I infer that you are permanently done with your project
> > > and you won't be updating the code yourselves any further?
> >
> > Sorry but I thought that this is the right place for submitting new
> > source code?
> Oh sure, this would be the right place. From your wording, it sounded that
> you expected some other developers to take your code and merge it to VLC.
> If you want to submit the code, you should format it as a (set of) git-
> formatted patches on top of VLC 1.2.0.
> In any case, there are a few minor issues in my opinion:
> * Seek returns VLC_SUCCESS even though it is not implemented.
> * Preprocessor constants should not have trailing semi-colons.
> * Indentation does not follow the VLC convention (4 white spaces).
> * Source code files should not be executable.
> * "https" scheme is registered, but apparently not implemented??
> * You should really use net_ConnectTCP(), net_Read(), net_Write() and
> net_Close() from <vlc_network.h> instead of custom IPv4-only non-
> Windows blocking-mode socket code.
> And last, I don't know how practical, but you should try to play nice with
> "normal" HTTP plugin.
Ok this should not be that hard to fix, unfortunately I have no time this
week but I will do it in the first week of March and inform you when it's

Best Regards

More information about the vlc-devel mailing list